The Detroit Tigers are actively exploring options to strengthen their roster before the MLB trade deadline, with a particular focus on upgrading third base due to inconsistent offensive production throughout the 2025 season. The team has relied heavily on Zach McKinstry to fill this role recently, but doing so limits his valuable versatility on the field. This situation has created urgency for the Tigers as they try to bolster their lineup in pursuit of postseason success.
Trade Targets Shift After Eugenio Suarez Deal
Initially, the Tigers pursued Arizona Diamondbacks slugger Eugenio Suarez to address their third base struggles, but the Mariners swooped in with a late-night acquisition on Wednesday, ending Detroit’s chances. With Suarez no longer available, the Tigers have turned their attention to veteran third baseman Nolan Arenado of the St. Louis Cardinals as a potential upgrade. This interest remains despite Arenado’s known no-trade clause, which complicates any trade negotiations.
Nolan Arenado Remains a Possible Fit Despite Obstacles
Jim Bowden of The Athletic shared on the Foul Territory podcast that the Tigers still stand as a plausible destination for Arenado. The main barrier remains Arenado’s no-trade clause, and notably, Detroit was not previously on his approved team list. However, the Tigers’ current strong position as one of the top teams in baseball might influence Arenado’s willingness to reconsider, especially as he seeks to join a contender likely to make a deep playoff run.
Arenado, an eight-time All-Star, has seen a decline in his offensive effectiveness in 2025, posting an .662 OPS and an 86 OPS+. Although his power numbers have slipped, his ability to make contact and limit strikeouts still offers some value. Defensively, he continues to be a strong presence at third base, which could contribute meaningfully to Detroit’s roster.
Evaluating the Potential Impact of an Arenado Acquisition
While Arenado’s glove work remains a strength, questions persist about how much of an upgrade he would represent compared to the existing Tigers players. His diminished offensive output raises concerns about whether the team’s resources might be better allocated toward other priorities as the trade deadline approaches. Detroit’s front office faces a challenging decision balancing short-term gains with long-term roster planning in a highly competitive American League Central.