FOX Sports analyst Nick Wright expressed skepticism about Justin Herbert‘s status as an elite NFL quarterback, questioning his accomplishments through the 2024 season. On the show First Things First, Wright argued that Herbert has yet to achieve the milestones that would place him comfortably among the top 15 quarterbacks in the league.
According to Wright, Herbert has demonstrated talent and flashes of potential, but none of these have translated into significant league-leading statistics or postseason success. Wright highlighted that Herbert has never topped any major NFL category and remains without a playoff victory for the Los Angeles Chargers, despite multiple postseason appearances.
“He just has to accomplish something. That’s all. Just accomplish something. He has shown me things… I’ve seen a lot of positive things from Justin Herbert. Just unfortunately, none of them have resulted in any tangible accomplishment. He’s never led the league in any category.
“He’s never won a playoff game. He hasn’t have even like the kind of marred accomplishment of an amazing regular season and then the playoff like 13 and 3, but then you lose in the playoff game. If we were to rank active starting quarterbacks by accomplishment, he doesn’t make the top 15.” —Nick Wright, FOX Sports Analyst
Reviewing Justin Herbert’s Career Since Being Drafted
Selected sixth overall in the 2020 NFL Draft by the Chargers, Herbert quickly became the centerpiece of Los Angeles’ offense. As an Oregon product, he brought impressive physical tools and arm talent into a franchise eager for consistency at quarterback. However, through five seasons, the Chargers have only reached the playoffs twice and failed to secure a postseason win with Herbert under center.
Herbert’s statistical output remains strong but incremental when measured against top-tier quarterbacks. This contrast fuels ongoing debate about whether his NFL quarterback achievements merit recognition within the league’s elite group or if he is still developing toward that goal.
Optimism Surrounding the Chargers’ 2025 Campaign
Heading into the 2025 season, Herbert looks to rebound following a solid 2024 campaign where he passed for 3,870 yards, 23 touchdowns, and only three interceptions. The Chargers finished 11-6, placing second in the AFC West behind the Super Bowl-bound Kansas City Chiefs. However, their playoff run ended in the first round with a loss to the Houston Texans.
Los Angeles has made notable roster improvements to enhance Herbert’s support system and boost postseason prospects. The acquisition of running back Najee Harris aims to complement rookie Omarion Hampton in the backfield, while guard Mekhi Becton, recently part of a Super Bowl-winning Eagles offensive line, was signed to strengthen pass protection.
These changes intend to address previous shortcomings and help the Chargers achieve that elusive playoff victory. Los Angeles will begin its 2025 regular season with a highly anticipated rematch against the Kansas City Chiefs on September 5, setting the stage for another chapter in Herbert’s pursuit of NFL success.
What’s Next for Justin Herbert and the Chargers?
The 2025 season could prove pivotal for Herbert’s career trajectory as he seeks to solidify his place among NFL quarterbacks with lasting impact. Wright’s critique underscores the pressure on Herbert to convert potential into tangible achievements, particularly a playoff win that would validate his performances.
If Herbert and the Chargers can capitalize on their roster upgrades and improve postseason results, they may shift public perception and quiet doubts about his quarterback accomplishments. As the season unfolds, Herbert’s ability to lead Los Angeles deeper into the playoffs will be closely watched by fans and analysts alike.