The Pittsburgh Penguins endured a difficult NHL season last year and are expected to remain near the bottom of the standings once again. Despite likely entering the early phases of a rebuild, several players are positioned to make significant bounce-back impacts in the 2025-26 season.
Erik Karlsson’s Challenge to Revive His Game
Erik Karlsson was acquired by Pittsburgh amid high expectations, given his reputation as one of the league’s top offensive defensemen. However, Karlsson has yet to regain his peak performance since joining the Penguins. Last season, he managed 11 goals and 42 assists, totaling 53 points, a noticeable decline from the 101-point season he had before arriving in Pittsburgh. Trade rumors have swirled around Karlsson’s name as he looks to elevate his play, potentially to increase interest from Cup contenders.
Kevin Hayes Aims to Reclaim Scoring Form
Veteran Kevin Hayes was added to bring experience and secondary scoring to the Penguins last season, but he struggled offensively, recording only 13 goals and 10 assists in 64 games. Hayes has the capability to be a physical presence and a 20-goal scorer. With his contract entering its final year, he faces pressure to enhance his performance and raise his value for potential trade opportunities.
Rutger McGroarty’s Opportunity to Establish Himself
Top prospect Rutger McGroarty, originally drafted 14th overall by Winnipeg in 2022, was traded to Pittsburgh after choosing not to sign with the Jets. In his rookie NHL season, McGroarty’s impact was limited; he appeared in just eight games and posted 1 goal and 2 assists. As he moves into a full-time role in the upcoming season, McGroarty will have the chance to demonstrate why he was regarded as one of the league’s premier young talents.
Prospects for the Penguins and Season Outlook
The 2025-26 season represents a critical juncture for these three key Penguins players as they strive to bounce back amid a team struggling to contend. Karlsson’s resurgence could reignite Pittsburgh’s defense, while Hayes and McGroarty need to solidify their roles to help stabilize the lineup. Their individual successes will be pivotal in shaping the team’s rebuild trajectory and future competitiveness in the NHL.