The New York Yankees made several key signings ahead of the 2025 MLB trade deadline to strengthen their roster, including acquiring relief pitcher Jake Bird from the Colorado Rockies. Despite his underwhelming 4.73 ERA with the Rockies earlier this season, Bird’s performance with the Yankees has been even more troubling. His struggles culminated in surrendering a three-run walk-off home run against the Texas Rangers, which led the Yankees to demote him to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre immediately after the game.
This move reflects the Yankees’ ongoing challenges this season, as the team has now fallen to third place in the American League East, sitting 2.5 games behind the division-leading Boston Red Sox. The demotion of Bird is a sign that the team’s bullpen issues remain unresolved despite their midseason acquisitions.
Fan Reaction Turns Negative Following Jake Bird’s Demotion
Yankees fans have expressed significant frustration and disbelief surrounding the trade and Jake Bird’s recent demotion. Many had hoped Bird would help solidify the bullpen, fueling optimism for a deep playoff run. Instead, his poor outings and the team’s broader struggles have sparked sharp criticism on social media.
Several fans vented their disappointment, highlighting how the trade appears to have favored the Rockies. One fan simply stated,
“Rockies won the trade.”
Other comments emphasized dissatisfaction with Yankees management and coaching. One user wrote,
“What a trade!!!!! Fire Boone and Cashman please,”
while another sarcastically remarked,
“But but but but the super bullpen.”
Some fans even called for other players to be sent down, with one chiming in,
“Don’t forget to send Devin and Volpe down there too. Thanks!”
Another expressed a bleak outlook, writing,
“It’s truly never been more over.”
The harsh tone is indicative of the anxiety and unease surrounding the Yankees’ current state.
Ongoing Struggles and Uncertain Road Ahead for Yankees
The Yankees’ slump has left fans anxious as the postseason approaches. While the team battles for a Wild Card spot, defensive issues have also contributed to their woes, with players like Anthony Volpe facing criticism for their performance. Additionally, pressure mounts on manager Aaron Boone, whose decisions are increasingly questioned by the fanbase.
With the Yankees having recently been swept by the Miami Marlins for the first time, calls for change, including Boone’s dismissal, have grown louder. The team’s inability to capitalize on midseason trades like Jake Bird highlights the challenges they face in reclaiming their winning form.
As the trade deadline excitement fades into disappointment, the Yankees must find ways to stabilize their bullpen and improve consistency if they hope to secure a postseason berth and satisfy their demanding fans.