Juan Soto’s ongoing New York Mets attitude controversy has grown as the team struggles early in the season. After several disappointing losses, media personalities in New York have publicly questioned Soto’s demeanor and leadership. This reaction intensified shortly after Soto broke up a no-hitter in the ninth inning against the Cleveland Guardians, yet appeared to exhibit a lack of urgency on the field.
The skepticism toward Soto, who carries a hefty $760 million contract, reflects the frustration with the Mets, who have lost eight of their last nine games. As one of the highest-paid players, many expect Soto to set a strong example and lead the team out of its slump, but critics argue his actions have fallen short of those expectations.
Local Radio Hosts Express Frustration Over Soto’s On-Field Conduct
WFAN hosts have become some of Soto’s harshest critics. Boomer Esiason, co-host of the “Boomer and Gio” morning show, spoke extensively about Soto’s attitude following the late-game hit. Esiason observed that Soto was not running hard to first base and appeared almost amused by the moment rather than focused and intense.
“When Juan Soto hit that ball he might have been thrown out at first base if it didn’t go out of the building because he’s loping out of the box,”
said Esiason.
“Now I don’t expect him to sprint to first base in a situation like this, but he watched the whole thing. This to me is a reoccurring.. and he’s got a nice smile on his face you know like he’s laughing. I’m sick of it. I want to see attitude.”
—Boomer Esiason, WFAN Host
He further referenced Mets legends such as Gary Carter and Ray Knight to emphasize the difference in leadership he expects from a player earning Soto’s salary. Esiason described the team as “overpaid and underwhelmed” and insisted that none of the Mets’ current roster justifies Soto’s contract if he doesn’t demonstrate clear leadership.
“Your highest-paid player, whether it be Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani or, in this case, Juan Soto, has to lead the team,”
Esiason added.
“They have to set the example. And when the example that is being set is one that just doesn’t look, at least to the naked eye, and as a former athlete looks to me like… If that’s the guy making $760 million and he’s supposed to be a leader, I’m not following that guy.”
—Boomer Esiason, WFAN Host
Wider Media Reaction and Fan Expectations
Other New York media figures like ESPN New York’s Michael Kay have also commented on Soto’s attitude, particularly regarding his reaction to missing the All-Star game. The backlash reflects a tense environment where Mets fans and media expect Soto to deliver not just on his individual talent, but also as a motivating presence.
The pressure on Soto is immense, particularly in light of the Mets’ high payroll and ambitions for a deep postseason run. Having already played in New York previously, Soto is familiar with the scrutiny that comes with being a public figure in the city’s highly competitive sports environment.
What Lies Ahead for Juan Soto and the Mets
Despite the negative coverage, the Mets organization and fans alike recognize that the season is still in its early stages. The current slump leaves room for adjustment, and the final judgment on Soto’s leadership and impact may not be made until the team’s performance stabilizes in the coming months.
If the Mets begin to win more consistently, attitudes—including those of leading players like Soto—are likely to be seen in a more positive light. A turnaround could shift perceptions from criticism to admiration, as smiles and composure may then symbolize confidence rather than detachment.