Tyler Allgeier’s rookie season was marked by a 1,000-yard rushing performance, a fact that often gets overlooked when evaluating his fantasy value. Since entering the <a href="https://www.buzzineintl.com/category/football/nfl/”>NFL, Allgeier has shown durability, missing only one game in three seasons while maintaining a high catch rate, ranking third among 68 running backs with at least 50 targets since 2022. This consistency combined with his receiving efficiency makes him a sensible late-round pick for fantasy managers as a backup or insurance option behind star running backs like Bijan Robinson.
While Bijan Robinson is widely regarded as one of the most promising young backs in the league, the presence of Allgeier in the Atlanta Falcons’ backfield offers fantasy players an intriguing opportunity. With Robinson’s high usage and durability, drafting Allgeier as a late-round insurance running back provides a safety net in case of injury, making him more than just a speculative choice.
What to Expect From Tyler Allgeier in 2025 Fantasy Football
Allgeier fits neatly into the category of dependable backup running backs who do not solely rely on injuries to become fantasy-relevant starters. Although his opportunity to take significant carries away from Robinson may be limited, Allgeier brings a reliable floor and upside that surpass many other backups currently available. His track record shows he produces slightly above expectations at the professional level, ranking 10th in production over expectation among running backs with a minimum of 500 carries, alongside names like Josh Jacobs and Kyren Williams.
Comparing Allgeier to other backups such as Jordan Mason, Cam Skattebo, and Jaydon Blue highlights his strong potential, even if his chances of assuming a major role are lower. However, his abilities and consistency make him a valuable asset on fantasy benches, especially for managers looking to hedge against risks associated with their starters.
Bijan Robinson’s Impact and the Value of Allgeier’s Backup Role
Bijan Robinson has not missed a game in his career and has handled 637 touches over 34 regular-season games, a workload that brings both high upside and inherent risk. This heavy usage shares similarities with legendary backs like Adrian Peterson, known for peak production but also prone to injury risks. Given this context, having Tyler Allgeier as a bench option offers a strategic advantage, as he would transition into a weekly start without matchup concerns should Robinson miss time.
With Robinson healthy, Allgeier remains a bench player and has rarely seen extensive workloads; he has surpassed 12 carries only once in his last 20 games, an occasion driven by a large in-game lead rather than a shift in his usual role. This clarity of role enhances his value as a dependable handcuff, an understandable flow chart for managers when determining weekly lineup decisions.
Why Allgeier Should Be Prioritized Over Other Backup Running Backs
When comparing Allgeier to other fantasy options such as Braelon Allens, Jaylen Wrights, JK Dobbins, and Austin Ekeler, Allgeier’s position is notable for stability and potential. Unlike some backups who depend heavily on injury scenarios to become fantasy starters, Allgeier’s consistent performance and the Falcons’ running back depth chart position him as a preferred choice for managers looking to reinforce their benches with meaningful upside.
Beyond the Falcons, drafting players like Zach Charbonnet, Isaac Guerendo, and Ray Davis serves as a similar strategy—targeting backups with a path to meaningful touches in case of starter injuries provides more flexibility. Pooling running backs across different backfields increases the chances for opportunities and touch volume, which are crucial for long-term fantasy success.
The Strategic Wisdom of Holding Tyler Allgeier in Fantasy Rosters
Fantasy football success requires not only star players but also strong bench depth capable of producing when called upon. Tyler Allgeier represents this balance as a runner who has proven his ability to produce efficiently when given chances and to stay on the field consistently. His rookie 1,000-yard campaign alongside impressive catch rate efficiency underlines a rare combination of skill and reliability.
Using Allgeier as insurance behind Bijan Robinson is a smart move, especially with Robinson’s heavy workload and the inherent injury risks that accompany it. Whereas many late-round picks are speculative flier receivers, Allgeier provides a clear and actionable contingency plan. This makes him an invaluable asset to draft late and hold confidently on your roster.
In the marathon of the NFL season, having a dependable backup like Tyler Allgeier allows fantasy managers to approach uncertainty with measured confidence, enhancing roster stability and maximizing long-term scoring opportunities.