The New York Yankees may see Aaron Judge back in the outfield as soon as this weekend when they face the St. Louis Cardinals. Judge has been playing as the designated hitter for the past week, but Yankees manager Aaron Boone indicated that a return to the field is possible soon. This opportunity would come at a critical time as the team attempts to improve its position in the AL East and the Wild Card race.
Elbow Injury Status and Recovery Progress
Judge was sidelined on July 22 due to a right flexor strain in his elbow, which caused more discomfort while throwing than during hitting. He was placed on the 10-day injured list after tests confirmed that his UCL remained intact. Despite this, Judge’s elbow has been recovering rapidly, which raises hope among the Yankees for his early return to defensive duties.
Giancarlo Stanton’s Role Amid Judge’s Injury
While Judge has taken on the DH role, Giancarlo Stanton has been covering right field. Stanton has not played in the outfield since September 14, 2023, and is also managing his own elbow issues this season. However, the Yankees rely heavily on Stanton’s bat, making his presence in the lineup essential despite concerns about his defensive capabilities. To accommodate both players, the Yankees front office has made several unusual lineup choices.
Concerns Over Playing Conditions in St. Louis
Andy Martino from SNY expressed doubts about Judge’s readiness for the upcoming Cardinals series and questioned Stanton’s ability to cover right field effectively. Martino highlighted that Yankee Stadium’s right field is relatively small, suiting Stanton’s limited range at this stage, whereas Busch Stadium in St. Louis offers far more ground to cover, potentially complicating matters defensively for the Yankees.
Right field at Yankee Stadium is relatively small, which is suited to Stanton’s current level of speed and range,
—Andy Martino, SNY Analyst
Busch Stadium in St. Louis presents far more ground to cover.
—Andy Martino, SNY Analyst
Yankees Preparing for a Critical Stretch
Judge and Stanton recently lined up together against the Minnesota Twins in their “Freaky Friday” roles, with Judge as DH and Stanton in right field. The Yankees secured a win in their first game against the Twins but remain under pressure with a 4-7 record since the trade deadline. Currently sitting third in the AL East and holding the last Wild Card spot, the team needs strong performances from both players as they navigate this challenging phase of the season.
Implications for the Yankees’ Season Outlook
Aaron Judge’s potential return to the outfield could provide a much-needed boost for the Yankees as they approach an essential series against the Cardinals. Giving Judge a chance to resume his defensive role would allow the team to fully leverage his all-around skills while also easing the burden on Stanton. How well both adapt to the upcoming schedule will likely play a significant role in the Yankees’ efforts to climb back into playoff contention this season.