When the Indianapolis Colts selected Anthony Richardson as the fourth overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, they envisioned him as the future cornerstone of the franchise and possibly a league superstar. However, since entering the NFL, Richardson has appeared in just 15 of 34 potential games, raising significant questions about his availability and growth. The Colts’ concerns over Anthony Richardson Colts injury concerns have become more pronounced, prompting them to sign former first-round quarterback Daniel Jones to a $14 million contract this offseason.

Competition for Starting Role Heightened by Early Injury Setback

Both Richardson and Jones are expected to compete for the Colts’ starting quarterback position, but Richardson’s injury during the preseason opener has complicated the situation. Sports Illustrated’s Albert Breer pointed out that Richardson’s injury partly stemmed from a lack of field awareness.

“To some degree the way the injury to Anthony Richardson happened explained where he is as a player. That he didn’t recognize, or see, what was coming on the play isn’t a great sign for where he is developmentally.”

—Albert Breer, Sports Illustrated

Raw Talent Struggles to Translate into Consistent Performance

Richardson entered the league as one of the most unpolished first-round quarterback prospects in recent years, particularly given the modern NFL’s emphasis on readiness. His current struggles appear to reflect this inexperience. Despite the setbacks, Richardson is still only 23 years old, leaving room for growth. For comparison, the New Orleans Saints recently drafted second-round pick Tyler Shough, who is already 25, suggesting there is time for young quarterbacks to develop their skills.

Colts’ Patience Will Be Tested as Season Approaches

As Richardson approaches his third NFL season, the Colts face a critical decision on whether to maintain patience with his growth or demand quicker progress. The team’s confidence in Richardson’s long-term potential remains tempered by his limited availability and in-game recognition abilities. The upcoming season will reveal how much leeway Indianapolis is willing to extend to Richardson amid competition from Daniel Jones and ongoing injury concerns.