Devin Williams, once a dominant force for the Milwaukee Brewers, has experienced a difficult 2025 season since being traded to the New York Yankees in December. Despite his previous success, Williams has posted a 5.60 ERA over 49 outings this year, marking his worst performance since joining the major leagues. His struggles have left many wondering if his next contract will reflect his recent decline rather than his historic dominance.
The Brewers received two players in the trade, but only one, Nestor Cortes, has appeared in games for Milwaukee, making the exchange look favorable for the Brewers so far. Williams’ poor showing this season has been tough for fans to watch, especially as he heads toward free agency with diminished market value.
Could Milwaukee Be the Ideal Destination for a Comeback?
Speculation emerged recently over whether Devin Williams might return to the Brewers, the team where he flourished in previous years. Robert Murray of FanSided highlighted Milwaukee as one of three teams that could “embarrass” the Yankees by signing Williams and helping him regain his two-time All-Star form.
“Wouldn’t that be something if the Brewers traded Williams and then signed him back as a free agent?”
—Robert Murray, FanSided
“The Brewers know Williams well and he knows the organization well. If he wants the best chance at re-establishing his value, perhaps Milwaukee is the place for him. Again, I can’t see this happening. But I’ve been surprised before.”
—Robert Murray, FanSided
Murray expresses both hope and skepticism regarding Williams’ return, citing the pitcher’s uncertain market and recent performance as key obstacles. Yet, the possibility remains intriguing given Williams’ familiarity with the Brewers’ system and his past success in Milwaukee.
Remembering Williams’ Peak Performance with the Brewers
To appreciate why a return might make sense for both Williams and the Brewers, it helps to recall his dominance in Milwaukee. Williams earned the National League Reliever of the Year award twice, posting a remarkable 1.83 ERA and holding opposing hitters to a .157 batting average during his tenure. Such numbers underline his potential if he can rediscover his form.
Adjustments to his pitching mechanics, such as his arm slot or delivery, could be key factors in regaining his previous effectiveness. For a team looking to bolster its bullpen without a large financial commitment, a short-term deal to bring Williams back might be a calculated risk worth taking.
What the Future Holds for Devin Williams and the Brewers
As Williams approaches free agency, the possibility of him re-signing with Milwaukee remains an open question. While his 2025 campaign has cast doubt on his value, the familiarity between player and organization might offer a mutually beneficial opportunity to revive his career. If the Brewers decide to explore this path, fans could witness a captivating redemption story.
Until then, Brewers supporters will watch with mixed emotions, hopeful yet uncertain about Williams’ next moves. Whatever happens, his tenure with the Yankees marks a low point from which a notable comeback could emerge, especially if Milwaukee extends an offer that aligns with both parties’ interests.