New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso became the franchise‘s all-time home run leader on August 12, surpassing Darryl Strawberry‘s previous record of 252 home runs. Shortly after breaking the record, Alonso sparked controversy by writing “Down Goes Straw!” on the game ball commemorating his milestone, drawing mixed reactions from fans and observers.
Alonso Surpasses Mets Home Run Milestone Amidst Nostalgic Comparisons
Pete Alonso‘s ascent to the top of the Mets’ home run leaderboard naturally invited conversations about his relationship with former Mets great Darryl Strawberry. In an August 10 interview with Mike Puma of the New York Post, Alonso expressed admiration for Strawberry, emphasizing the significance of their face-to-face connection.
“The fact that [Strawberry and I] have an in-person, face-to-face relationship is awesome,”
Alonso said.
“He’s just one of those guys that means so much to this organization.”
At the time of the interview, Alonso and Strawberry were tied at 252 home runs each, marking the highest total in Mets history. Alonso then hit two more homers, officially setting the new franchise record and solidifying his place in Mets lore as the leading home run hitter.
Controversy Erupts Over Alonso’s Inscription on Record-Breaking Home Run Ball
Following Alonso’s historic achievement during the August 12 game, a fan presented him with the record home run ball. Alongside signing his autograph, Alonso wrote several messages on the ball, notably including the phrase, “Down Goes Straw!”—a clear reference to Darryl Strawberry, who previously held the record.
The photo of the ball featuring Alonso’s inscriptions quickly circulated on social media and prompted a polarized response. Many fans viewed the message as disrespectful, given the reverence surrounding Strawberry’s legendary status in Mets history. The phrasing was seen as provocative, especially so soon after Alonso had eclipsed a sentimental milestone.
I can’t get over this. I am not a Pete Alonso hater. I am generally neutral on him (even though he’s a Met, I have no specific hatred of him). Why did he write “Down Goes Straw” on this ball? Maybe he didn’t write it? It’s unfathomably lame. Have some respect. pic.twitter.com/kSob8eMamd
—Spike Eskin, Twitter User
Fans expressed frustration and disappointment over Alonso’s choice of words, debating whether such a statement fitted the respectful legacy associated with Strawberry’s record.
Darryl Strawberry Responds to Alonso’s Message With Understanding and Support
On August 14, Darryl Strawberry appeared on WFAN sports radio during an interview with Sal Licata and Brandon Tierney, where he addressed Alonso’s message on the home run ball. Strawberry maintained a gracious stance, stating he harbored no ill feelings about the inscription.
No, I don’t have an issue with that,
Strawberry commented.
Like I said, I’m not here to critique players. They have their right to do whatever they need to do. And if that’s the way he feels about it, then more power to him.
Strawberry continued by praising Alonso’s character and dedication, acknowledging the pressures the young player faces, especially during free agency negotiations.
I’m happy for him, he’s a good kid, he wants to win, he’s trying his best to do the best he can with what he has. Especially what he has been through, going through free agency, nobody wants [that],
Strawberry added.
Did Darryl Strawberry have any issue with the “Down goes Straw” inscription on Pete Alonso’s HR ball? He shares his thoughts with @BrandonTierney and @sal_licata: pic.twitter.com/4Df7ZjAVlV
—WFAN Sports Radio, Twitter Account
By publicly taking a composed and supportive approach, Strawberry defused some tension surrounding Alonso’s message, emphasizing respect and understanding for the new record holder.
Implications of the Record and Public Reaction Moving Forward
Pete Alonso’s achievement in becoming the Mets’ all-time home run leader marks a significant chapter in the franchise’s history, yet the controversy around his “Down Goes Straw!” message underscores the passionate attachments fans and former players have to team legends. While some view Alonso’s message as a playful taunt befitting competitive sportsmanship, others consider it an unnecessary jab at a revered figure.
Strawberry’s measured reaction has helped temper the heated debate, but the incident highlights the complicated balance current players face when surpassing historic milestones. As Alonso continues his career, how he navigates respect for the past alongside his personal ambition will shape his legacy with Mets fans and the broader baseball community.