Once hailed as a rising star in Fantasy Baseball during the 2025 season, Pete Crow-Armstrong is now facing a troubling slump that has led to significant questions about his playing time and fantasy value heading into 2026. The Cubs outfielder, who showed early-season promise, has struggled heavily in the second half, casting doubt over his status as a reliable fantasy asset.
Crow-Armstrong’s impressive start was marked by his blend of athleticism both offensively and defensively. However, his inconsistent plate discipline became more apparent as the season progressed, with an unusually high chase rate indicating poor pitch selection. These early warning signs have now translated into a severe slump, as his performance deteriorates well below expectations.
Performance Metrics Highlight A Slump
During the second half of the season, Crow-Armstrong’s statistics show a marked downturn. He has hit just .205/.239/.398 overall, with his August numbers even more concerning—a .193 OPS that signals a significant drop-off in production. His strikeout rate has spiked to 36%, and his expected weighted On-Base Average (wOBA) has fallen to .250, confirming that his struggles are more than just a temporary phase.
While slumps are a normal part of baseball, the timing and severity of his downturn have alarmed analysts and fantasy players alike. This decline is particularly troubling given that only a month ago, Crow-Armstrong was viewed by some as a top fantasy prospect for the season’s second half.
Playing Time Threatened by Emerging Competition
Crow-Armstrong’s playing time concerns were amplified following the Cubs’ decision to call up highly regarded prospect Owen Caissie for his Major League debut. Crow-Armstrong was notably left out of the lineup on the day Caissie debuted, reigniting questions about how crowded the Cubs’ outfield will be moving forward. With established players Ian Happ, Kyle Tucker, and Willi Castro, plus designated hitter Seiya Suzuki, the Cubs have a surplus of starting-caliber outfielders.
If Caissie secures a regular role, Crow-Armstrong could face increased days off, particularly if his offensive struggles continue. While his elite defense in center field has been a strong factor in keeping him in the lineup, the offense’s need for consistent production might force the team to prioritize stronger bats, narrowing Crow-Armstrong’s opportunities.
Offensive Challenges Against Left-Handed Pitching
Another factor working against Crow-Armstrong is his poor performance against left-handed pitchers. This season, he has batted just .190/.219/.408 versus southpaws, making it easier for the Cubs to consider platoon options on days facing left-handed starters. The Cubs, currently five games ahead of the Reds, still hold a playoff spot, but with the Brewers dominating the NL Central, their cushion for error is slim, making strategic lineup decisions paramount.
Implications for Crow-Armstrong’s Fantasy Value in 2026
The combination of offensive struggles and potential playing time reductions suggests Crow-Armstrong might no longer be a full-time player for the remainder of the season. If he enters a platoon role, he could lose around 25% of his plate appearances, severely impacting his fantasy output, particularly in points-based leagues where his plate discipline is already a liability.
While Crow-Armstrong’s baserunning and power on the pull side provide some fantasy relevance, his value is unlikely to match the heights seen in the first half of 2025. Should his slump persist, fantasy managers will need to reevaluate his draft position for 2026, potentially moving him down draft boards despite his 30-30 potential being within reach if he rebounds.
This makes Crow-Armstrong one of the more uncertain fantasy players poised for the upcoming season, as his continued slump and the crowded outfield situation in Chicago create significant risks for his long-term outlook. As of now, his first-half brilliance seems distant if these trends continue.
Notable Developments from Thursday’s MLB Action
Promising Waiver Wire Additions to Watch
Dylan Crews, outfielder for the Washington Nationals, made his return Thursday after nearly three months sidelined by an oblique injury. Despite a modest .620 OPS this season, the Nationals placed Crews second in the batting order against pitcher Jesus Luzardo. Though part of this decision may have been due to CJ Abrams’ absence, it shows the team’s intent to maximize Crews’ opportunities to regain form. He contributed with a 1-for-3 showing, a walk, and a steal, highlighting his impressive speed and base-running ability, which should keep him a player to watch in fantasy leagues.
Brenton Doyle, outfielder for the Colorado Rockies, has been overlooked in many fantasy drafts due to a difficult first half and limited track record. However, with Coors Field as his home ground and recent surge with a .393 batting average, four homers, two steals, and a 1.029 OPS in the second half, Doyle’s value is rising. He has missed three of the past eleven games but may see increased playing time if he continues to perform well. While not highly relevant in points leagues, Doyle remains a useful asset in Roto leagues.
Jordan Lawlar, shortstop for the Arizona Diamondbacks, was activated from the injured list at Triple-A following a hamstring injury. At just 23 years old, Lawlar’s minor league performance has been strong, boasting a .334/.420/.590 slash line with 17 homers and 22 steals in 81 games. The Diamondbacks are likely to promote him soon, adding valuable infield depth with eligibility at second base and possibly third base, making him a key prospect to monitor for 2026 and beyond.