As fantasy football managers prepare for the 2025 NFL season, Brandon Aubrey has emerged as the leading choice in the highly competitive fantasy football kicker category. While kickers are often overlooked during drafts, they remain crucial for securing consistent points. Aubrey’s standout performance last year has propelled him ahead of longtime favorite Justin Tucker, making the Brandon Aubrey fantasy football kicker option an essential consideration for fantasy rosters this season.
Top Tier Kickers Setting the Standard
Brandon Aubrey, representing the Dallas Cowboys, tops the kicker rankings after demonstrating remarkable range and volume last season. He made the longest field goal in the NFL with a 65-yard kick and attempted 47 field goals, the highest in the league. His aggressive scoring opportunities make him a premier target. Close contenders in the elite tier include Cameron Dicker of the Los Angeles Chargers and Jake Bates of the Detroit Lions, who both bring formidable kicking accuracy and scoring potential.
Bates led the NFL in extra points made with 64 last season, showcasing his reliability beyond just field goals. Meanwhile, Dicker boasts a career field goal completion rate of 93.8% over three NFL seasons, underscoring his consistency and dependability in clutch moments. This group stands apart as the top choices for fantasy managers valuing both opportunity and efficiency.
Strong Performers in the Middle Ranks
The next tier features kickers such as Will Lutz from the Denver Broncos, Chris Boswell of the Pittsburgh Steelers, Chase McLaughlin with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Harrison Butker from the Kansas City Chiefs, and Ka’imi Fairbairn representing the Houston Texans. Among these, Boswell stands out after leading the NFL with 41 field goals made last year and earning first-team All-Pro honors with a field goal accuracy exceeding 93% for two consecutive seasons. This notable achievement moved him up in rankings and establishes him as a reliable asset for fantasy teams.
Lutz benefits from favorable home conditions, including altitude, which often aids his kicking range. McLaughlin matches Boswell’s accuracy, maintaining above 93% field goal conversions for the past two seasons while kicking for one of the league’s most potent offenses. Butker and Fairbairn each posted around 85% in field goals made during 2024 but have shown better percentages in previous seasons, making them solid picks with potential for bounce-back performances.
Late-Round Options with Upside and Risks
Fantasy managers who prefer to wait on selecting kickers can consider options in the third tier, which includes Tyler Bass from the Buffalo Bills, Evan McPherson of the Cincinnati Bengals, Jake Elliott representing the Philadelphia Eagles, Younghoe Koo for the Atlanta Falcons, Matt Gay with the Washington Commanders, Jason Sanders of the Miami Dolphins, Will Reichard from the Minnesota Vikings, and Tyler Loop, a rookie drafted by the Baltimore Ravens.
Within this group, Sanders delivered the most consistent performance in 2024, making 90.2% of his field goals and converting 92.9% of extra points. Both Elliott and Koo have shown elite capabilities in previous seasons but struggled last year, which introduces some uncertainty for fantasy managers relying on their performance. McPherson also experienced a downturn, dropping to 72.7% field goal accuracy last season after never falling below 82.8% before.
Bass benefits from playing behind a strong Buffalo offense but faces challenging weather conditions during key fantasy playoff weeks. Gay’s career accuracy is about 85.5%, although recent seasons have fallen short of that standard. The youngest options, Reichard and Loop, are viewed as potential sleepers but carry notable risks due to limited track records and inconsistent shooting percentages.
The Importance of Smart Kicker Selection in Fantasy Football
While kickers are typically the last position to be drafted, their contribution to a fantasy football lineup should not be underestimated. The 2025 rankings show that selecting the right kicker, like Brandon Aubrey, can provide a competitive edge through both scoring volume and consistency. Managers should balance the need to wait on this position with the risk of losing top performers to rivals.
As the NFL season approaches, these rankings highlight how a few key kickers differentiate themselves by opportunity, accuracy, or favorable circumstances. With established stars like Justin Tucker no longer dominating the position, fantasy managers must remain alert and evaluate each kicker’s potential to influence weekly outcomes.