Montreal Canadiens defenseman Lane Hutson, the 2024-25 Calder Trophy winner as the NHL’s best rookie, has become a central figure in contract discussions this summer. His outstanding performance has sparked speculation about a significant long-term agreement, positioning him as a top candidate for a high-value deal.
NHL insider Stu Cowan shared his assessment on The Sick podcast, suggesting that an eight-year contract in the $8-9 million annual range would be a fair offer for the 21-year-old. He emphasized that this range balances Hutson’s rookie status and potential without undervaluing his contributions.
“If you’re offering him eight years at $8 million or $9 million,” Cowan said. “I don’t think you’re insulting the kid, right? I don’t think – that’s a lot of money for a kid with one season in the NHL, 21 years old, size worries or concerns. I don’t think you’re insulting them at any point in that time.”
Cowan warned that hesitating to finalize the deal could increase the financial burden, as Hutson’s value might rise if he maintains his high-quality play. Should Hutson continue his 2025-26 season in the same form as last year, the team might face offers exceeding $10 million during the season. While it’s not confirmed whether Hutson is currently demanding that amount, Cowan noted the potential for costs to climb with delays.
“For me, right now, I look at Cale Makar, okay,” Cowan said. “I know the salary Cap’s going up. I know it’s changing, and guys are going to be getting more money. But four years ago (Makar signed in July 2021), he signed a six-year contract with $9 million at 23 years old, Lane Hutson’s 21.”
Host Tony Marinaro referenced past deals, citing Erik Karlsson’s $11.5 million annual average value (AAV) contract valued at $92 million and Seth Jones’ $9.5 million AAV agreement. Cowan disagreed with Karlsson’s contract size, labeling it a misstep in hindsight.
“Yeah, that is a mistake,” Cowan said.
Regarding the timing of negotiations, Cowan noted Canadiens general manager Kent Hughes appears unwilling to rush the talks. He stressed that both the player and management require ample time to reach a balanced agreement.
“I don’t see any reason for them to rush into this right now,” Cowan said. “Lane Hutson, is he going to be offended that they didn’t give him a contract early? Well, there’s two sides. …You’re offering them, whatever offer is on the table. Now, I imagine there must be one.
Cowan pointed out the risks Hutson faces by not signing promptly, including the potential loss of earnings if injury strikes before an agreement is reached.
“I’m sure at the end of the day the Canadians are going to sign Lane Hutson,” Cowan said.
He concluded that while Hutson will likely be locked in by the Canadiens, an immediate eight-year contract is not necessary at this stage.
Lane Hutson’s Stellar Rookie Season Draws High Praise
Hutson’s debut season left a strong impression, as he tallied six goals and 60 assists, totaling 66 points over 82 games. His performance led all rookie defensemen in points and ice time, with his 60 assists matching Larry Murphy for the most ever by a rookie defenseman in NHL history.
Former Canadiens defenseman Serge Savard expressed admiration for Hutson’s talent, comparing him to one of the franchise’s all-time greats.
“Time will tell (about Hutson), but he’s probably the most talented player the (Montreal) Canadiens have had since Guy Lafleur.”
Despite Hutson’s individual success, the Canadiens’ postseason ended abruptly. Montreal was swept in the first round of the playoffs, losing 4-1 in Game 5 to the Washington Capitals. Challenges with physicality and turnovers among young defensemen, including Hutson, along with insufficient depth scoring and key injuries to goalkeepers, contributed to the team‘s early elimination.
Implications of Contract Decisions For the Canadiens
The ongoing contract discussions involving Hutson carry weighty implications for the Canadiens’ future. Settling on an appropriate deal will impact the team‘s salary cap and roster building as they seek to rebound from a frustrating playoff exit. The parallel drawn between Hutson’s anticipated contract and past deals, like Cale Makar’s and Erik Karlsson’s, underscores the financial pressures facing management.
Ultimately, how Montreal navigates this negotiation will influence the player’s development path and the team‘s competitiveness. The stakes are high as the Canadiens must balance rewarding promising talent with maintaining long-term roster flexibility.