
The St. Louis Cardinals are currently without one of their key contributors, Brendan Donovan, who is sidelined due to ongoing toe and leg pain. Despite the uncertainty surrounding his return, Donovan has expressed a strong desire to get back on the field soon, providing a hopeful update amid concerns over his health.
Donovan’s Role and Current Health Status With the Cardinals
Brendan Donovan has emerged as a vital player for the Cardinals this season, earning an All-Star selection thanks to his impressive performance both offensively and defensively. Through 110 games, he has maintained a solid batting line of .279/.348/.402, including nine home runs, 45 RBIs, 25 doubles, and 57 runs scored. Since the departure of Paul Goldschmidt, Donovan has also taken on a leadership role within the team. However, persistent toe and leg pain have forced him out of action recently, leaving the Cardinals without a crucial part of their lineup as they push through the 2025 season.
His absence has raised questions about when exactly the Cardinals can expect him to return. Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch shared that Donovan is hopeful to avoid a stint on the Injured List, aiming for a quick recovery through rest and treatment instead.
“Less certain is when the Cardinals can expect Donovan’s return, and if the pain lingers or they need a move to create time for Scott to recover an IL stint helps reinforce the bench,”
Goold reported.

Donovan’s Perspective on His Injury and Future Playing Time
Donovan himself spoke candidly about his condition and willingness to return as soon as possible. He told the Post-Dispatch,
“I’d love to play in a couple of days. Obviously, it’s based off of what the team needs. I want to play. I don’t want to miss time. Unfortunately, this has been bugging me for a large portion of the season.”
His statements reveal the personal conflict and urgency he feels to contribute, despite the discomfort and risk involved with his injury.
Implications of Donovan’s Injury on the Cardinals’ Season
Though the Cardinals‘ chances for making the playoffs this year appear slim, maintaining stability in the lineup remains a priority. Donovan’s presence adds value to the team’s offensive and defensive efforts, and his absence has noticeably impacted the Cardinals’ consistency. The slow-down in his production in the season’s second half can likely be attributed to these lingering health issues. The Cardinals will need him back at full strength to boost both morale and performance as they continue through the season.
It remains crucial for the team to balance the urgency of Donovan’s return against the risk of aggravating his injury further. Fans and teammates alike will be closely watching his recovery progress, hopeful for a timely but cautious return to action. The situation underscores the challenges the Cardinals face as they navigate injuries while striving to remain competitive.