As the 2025 NFL season approaches, certain players remain reliable choices for fantasy football success, including established stars like Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, Derrick Henry, and Ja’Marr Chase. However, some key athletes face increasing uncertainty, making them risky assets in dynasty fantasy football leagues. Managers should consider parting ways with these individuals before their values potentially decline further.
Examining Patrick Mahomes’ Unexpected Decline
It may seem surprising to associate Patrick Mahomes with the term “bust,” yet the Kansas City Chiefs‘ quarterback experienced a notable downturn in 2024. Mahomes recorded career lows with 3,928 passing yards and 26 touchdowns, a sharp contrast to previous dominant seasons. Despite the Chiefs’ overall success, winning 15 games, Mahomes was less pivotal, partly due to a stronger running game that eased the pressure on him. This trend casts doubt on his fantasy value heading into 2025.
Other Top Players Facing Fantasy Value Challenges
Saquon Barkley delivered a historic effort with the New York Giants in 2024, rushing for over 2,000 yards despite obstacles, but expecting him to maintain that extraordinary level is unrealistic. Barkley remains capable of explosive plays, yet his peak season may remain unmatched.
Garrett Wilson’s anticipated breakout has yet to materialize, even when paired with Aaron Rodgers. The transition to a mobile quarterback like Justin Fields, who struggled to connect with George Pickens last season, does not inspire confidence in Wilson’s fantasy upside.
Tyreek Hill’s 2023 season was exceptional within Miami’s high-flying offense, nearly surpassing 2,000 receiving yards. However, questions linger about his future with the Dolphins and his chemistry with quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, making his fantasy prospects uncertain.
Baker Mayfield showcased impressive numbers in 2024 with 4,500 passing yards and 41 touchdowns, a performance boosted by the offensive system he was in. With Liam Coen stepping in as Jacksonville Jaguars head coach, it remains unclear whether Mayfield can match last year’s output.
Running Backs and Wide Receivers with Uncertain Roles
Breece Hall faces stiff competition in 2025 from teammates Justin Fields, Braelon Allen, and Isaiah Davis. Though reliable, Hall’s opportunity for touches could decline due to the crowded backfield in New York. Similarly, Chris Olave remains productive but suffers from the New Orleans Saints’ quarterback uncertainties and the overall team struggles that could stunt his fantasy value.
George Pickens, now with the Dallas Cowboys, has yet to establish a strong rapport with Dak Prescott, unlike other top receivers on the team. This lack of connection may limit his fantasy production despite his perceived talent.
Rome Odunze’s role with the Chicago Bears is still evolving in his second season. Offensive coordinator Ben Johnson might use him similarly to Javonte Williams, but competition for this role and an uncertain target share create ambiguity around Odunze’s fantasy potential, even with Keenan Allen sidelined.
Health and Availability Concerns Impacting Fantasy Outlooks
Joe Mixon impressed in his first season with the Houston Texans, but his injury during training camp raises concerns about his availability at the start of 2025. While Mixon could remain a flexible option when healthy, doubts about his physical condition temper enthusiasm for his fantasy outlook.
Implications for Dynasty Fantasy Football Managers Ahead of 2025
For dynasty fantasy football managers, recognizing these ten players as potential busts could prove critical. Selling or trading these athletes before the season begins may help avoid significant value drops, particularly given the uncertainty surrounding Patrick Mahomes’ 2025 performance after his statistical decline in 2024. As teams like the Kansas City Chiefs adjust their offensive strategies and other players face competition or injuries, fantasy managers must stay vigilant in evaluating roster risks.