The Philadelphia Eagles are considering a significant move regarding their backup quarterback Tanner McKee as shifting player valuations create new trade possibilities. With Anthony Richardson’s market value declining, the Eagles are exploring the chance to improve their quarterback roster by potentially exchanging McKee with a team willing to offer draft capital in return.
Among the teams reportedly in discussions is the Indianapolis Colts, who may emerge as a crucial participant in any trade negotiations involving McKee and Richardson.
Trade environment reflects changing player values between Eagles and Colts
Industry analyst Max Dible highlights a prospective trade scenario where the Eagles might acquire Anthony Richardson, a former first-round pick, from the Colts, along with a sixth-round pick in the 2026 draft. Meanwhile, Tanner McKee’s value has risen since his selection in the sixth round in 2023, contrasting with Richardson’s recent decline in standing.
The Colts’ position as an AFC team adds to their appeal as a trade partner since a quarterback returned to their division would not present a direct threat to the Eagles. The Colts see potential in Richardson as a backup to Jalen Hurts for the upcoming seasons, despite Richardson’s struggles including injuries and inconsistent performances that have jeopardized his starting role amid Daniel Jones becoming Indianapolis’ primary quarterback.
Anthony Richardson’s uncertain future and challenges in Indianapolis
Richardson’s status became unstable after Colts head coach Shane Steichen named Daniel Jones as the starting quarterback, signaling reduced confidence in Richardson’s reliability. His agent, Detric Jackson, conveyed dissatisfaction about trust issues surrounding Richardson’s position, stating,
“Trust is a big factor and that is, at best, questionable right now.” —Detric Jackson, Agent
These concerns followed Richardson being benched for two games during the 2024 season, including one loss to the Houston Texans reportedly linked to doubts regarding his level of commitment.
Despite these complications, Richardson’s notable physical traits—standing 6-foot-4 and weighing 244 pounds—continue to attract interest from teams willing to invest in his athleticism and upside. Though his career statistics include 13 interceptions against 11 touchdowns and a quarterback rating of 67.8, his 8-7 record as a starter over two seasons suggests potential that some organizations believe stems more from external factors such as coaching inconsistency within the Colts franchise.
Potential benefits for the Eagles in acquiring Anthony Richardson
The Eagles view Richardson as a quarterback whose dual-threat skill set resembles current starter Jalen Hurts, offering a unique developmental opportunity. Bringing him into Philadelphia could allow the team to build on his potential over the next two years, enhancing his value and possibly setting the stage for a profitable future trade.
By pursuing Richardson, the Eagles aim to strengthen their quarterback depth while investing in a player who has yet to fully realize his talent but possesses the physical tools to improve under the right conditions.
Impact of a Tanner McKee trade on both Philadelphia and Indianapolis
Trading Tanner McKee could initiate a strategic shift for both franchises; Philadelphia might secure a backup quarterback with growth prospects, while the Colts could acquire a rising talent ready to compete for playing time or develop further. This transaction underscores the evolving quarterback market and the Eagles’ willingness to adapt their roster amid player value fluctuations.
As discussions continue, the outcome of these trade talks could influence the quarterback landscape in the NFL, particularly for the Eagles and Colts, as both teams seek to address immediate needs and plan for future competitiveness.