Former NFL defensive end Chris Canty, who once played alongside Eli Manning, expressed strong doubts about Aaron Rodgers’ potential to succeed as the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback in the upcoming 2024 season. Canty questioned Rodgers’ effectiveness despite the star quarterback signing a one-year contract with the Steelers, aimed at boosting the team’s chances.
Canty argued that Rodgers’ best years are behind him and doubted that the four-time NFL MVP could elevate the Steelers’ performance this year. His concerns focus on Rodgers’ physical condition and ongoing challenges as he ages.
Concerns Over Rodgers’ Health and Performance Decline
On ESPN First Take, Canty clearly stated,
“It’s because I don’t believe in the quarterback. I just don’t,”
highlighting his lack of faith in Rodgers’ ability. He criticized the narrative that Rodgers’ recent struggles are solely due to injuries, saying that age and declining health simply cannot be ignored. Canty remarked,
“as players get older, they don’t get healthier,”
casting doubt on Rodgers’ durability for the demanding season ahead.
He further pointed out Rodgers’ limited mobility as a factor that could lead to increased sacks, severely hindering the Steelers’ offensive outcomes. According to Canty, this decrease in agility makes it difficult to envision Rodgers improving on Pittsburgh’s performance over the past five years.
Performance Comparison Highlights Doubts from Canty
Drawing on recent examples, Canty compared Rodgers’ impact with that of quarterback situations elsewhere, particularly the New York Jets. Canty noted,
“We saw with the New York Jets they were better off without him than they were with him with the combination of Trevor Siemian, Tim Boyle and Zach Wilson.”
He added that the Jets won two more games despite Rodgers starting every game in 2024, suggesting that Rodgers did not provide a net positive influence.
These observations contribute to Canty’s skepticism about Rodgers’ ability to “raise the floor” for the Steelers, implying that the team might not see substantial improvement despite acquiring a high-profile quarterback.
Rodgers Critiques Steelers’ Offensive Line
Amidst these evaluations, Aaron Rodgers himself has expressed frustrations with the Pittsburgh Steelers’ offensive line. His pointed comments indicate concerns over protection and offensive support, highlighting one of the challenges the team must address to maximize their new quarterback’s potential.
Canty’s doubts and Rodgers’ own criticisms underline an uneasy atmosphere surrounding the Steelers’ prospects for the 2024 NFL season. With questions about the quarterback’s health and support system, the team faces a pivotal year that could determine the success of their gamble on a veteran star.