Trevor Lawrence is currently under scrutiny in the ongoing Trevor Lawrence NFL career debate after analyst Bill Simmons openly criticized the Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback on his podcast, The Ringer. Simmons expressed doubt about Lawrence’s accuracy and overall development, suggesting his progress has stalled early in his career.
During the conversation, Simmons sharply stated,
“Trevor Lawrence, literally, he was one of my big guys last year. Yeah, he’s also not good. He’s not good at football,”
and added,
“I don’t think he’s accurate. I think he throws hospital balls left and right. If I was Brian Thomas Jr.’s family, I’d be terrified every game.”
—Bill Simmons, NFL Analyst
This critique came as Jacksonville completed joint practices with the Miami Dolphins, although Lawrence did not participate, focusing instead on preparing for Week 1. Simmons described the Jaguars’ organizational issues as “gangrene” that threatens to damage Lawrence’s growth as a quarterback. He blamed the team’s struggles for eroding Lawrence’s confidence and decision-making skills over time.
Positive Signs and Organizational Support for Lawrence
Despite Simmons’ bleak outlook, not everyone shares his view. Liam Coen, the Jaguars’ first-year head coach, has observed encouraging improvements in Lawrence’s approach and performance. Meanwhile, GM James Gladstone has been active throughout the offseason, adding weapons to strengthen the offense around the quarterback. The Jaguars hope these changes will help alter the trajectory of Lawrence’s career as the 2025 NFL season begins in September.
Lawrence Reflects on Challenges Faced Against Miami’s Defense
During the recent joint practices, Lawrence faced Miami’s defensive squad and noted the complexity it brings to preparing for games. He said,
“You get used to playing against your own defense and you see kind of the same disguises, so you start to pick up on certain things and you can protect it but when you’re seeing things for the first time.”
—Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback
The quarterback emphasized how difficult it can be to interpret defensive coverages without a complete game plan during preseason. He further commented on Miami’s defensive versatility:
“They do a nice job with man alignments and playing zone and zone alignments and playing man.”
—Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback
The Dolphins’ defense has earned respect for their ability to show one formation before changing it drastically after the snap, posing a challenge for quarterbacks trying to read defenses live.
Outlook for Trevor Lawrence and the Jaguars Moving Forward
The ongoing debate around Trevor Lawrence’s NFL career remains tense, reflecting the frustrations felt by many fans and analysts alike. While some like Bill Simmons doubt Lawrence’s ability to succeed long term, the Jaguars’ leadership appears committed to fostering his growth and addressing team weaknesses. How Lawrence responds to these pressures and improves his play this season will be critical for both his personal future and Jacksonville’s chances in the league.